Chef Sykesie
Lunch · Eggs

Egg mayo and cress sandwiches

A proper egg mayo sandwich with mustard, fresh cress and buttered bread. Cool the hard-boiled eggs before mixing the filling, then assemble the sandwiches just before eating.

Time
20 min
Prep
About 5 min
Boil and cool
10 min + 5 min cooling
Thick white-bread sandwich filled with chunky egg mayonnaise

Serving suggestion · Photo by jill, jellidonut... whatever · CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia crop by Anna Frodesiak, converted to WebP

Shop the kit Amazon ads

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Ingredients

0 of 7 ticked

Method

  1. Boil and cool the eggs

    Lower the eggs into gently boiling water and cook for 10 minutes. Move them to a bowl of cold water for 5 minutes before peeling.

    Move the eggs into cold water10:00
  2. Make the filling

    Roughly chop the eggs. Fold through the mayo and mustard, then season with a pinch of salt and plenty of pepper.

    What to look for A spoonful should hold together but still have pieces of egg in it. If it seems dry, mash a little yolk into the mayo before adding extra.

  3. Build the sandwiches

    Butter the bread. Spread the filling over half the bread slices, top with cress and close the sandwiches. Cut in half to serve.

Nutrition

Estimated per portion
Calories
576 kcal
Protein
21 g
Carbs
44.7 g
Fat
36.1 g
Fibre
2.6 g

Includes four 45g slices of soft white bread and about 5g of butter per slice.

Nutracheck’s My Meals guide ↗

In Nutracheck, use My Meals to build the recipe from the ingredient list, or use Quick Add to log the calories for one portion.

How the numbers are estimated

Estimates use UK food composition data and typical pack labels. Amounts assume 50g per egg without its shell and 13.5g oil per tablespoon. Optional extras and separate sides are excluded unless noted. Pack brands, ingredient sizes and cooking losses can change the figures.

Chef Sykesie Q&A

How long do I boil eggs for egg mayo?

Cook them for 10 minutes in gently boiling water, then move them straight into a bowl of cold water for 5 minutes before peeling.

How do I keep the filling chunky?

Roughly chop the cooled eggs and fold through the mayonnaise and Dijon. Stop mixing once the pieces are coated.

Can I make egg mayo without Dijon?

You can leave the mustard out or use a little mild wholegrain mustard. Taste the filling before adding the cress so you can adjust the seasoning.

How do I keep soft sandwich bread from going soggy?

Butter the inside of both slices, then add the egg mayo and cress. Keep the filling away from the edges so it stays in place when you cut the sandwich.

Can I use watercress in egg mayo sandwiches?

Yes. Pull off the tender leaves and add them just before serving. Watercress has larger, more peppery leaves than salad cress.

How should I keep leftovers?

Keep the filling covered in the fridge and add the cress just before assembly. It’s served cold. Keep sandwiches chilled if packing them for later. Cool cooked leftovers quickly and refrigerate within two hours. Use within 48 hours. If reheating, do it once and heat until steaming throughout. FSA leftovers guidance

Cook mode